苏格兰抵押投资信托 — 经理人回顾,截至2007年3月31日年报(詹姆斯·安德森)
过去一年取得了积极成果,资产净值、股价和基准指数均上涨了 39%。然而,在这一年中,股票市场的稳步上涨曾两次被短暂而剧烈的动荡所打断。2006 年 5 月和 6 月的市场冲击用了好几个月才得以修复,但迄今为止,今年 2 月底和 3 月初的下跌似乎更容易被克服。事实上,从我们自身角度看,最近这次波动的爆发是幸运的,因为它使我们得以推进下一阶段的发展——朝着一个真正全球化且不依赖指数的投资组合迈进。
实现这一目标的机会,因当今股票市场奇特的操作方式而得到加强。在动荡爆发时,投资银行、对冲基金以及大部分投资管理行业的普遍做法是查阅它们的风险模型,其方式与许多报纸读者查阅星座运势如出一辙——而成功的概率也大致相当。你应该卖出什么,取决于过去什么曾有过波动,即使导致这种历史波动的条件已不复存在,并且不顾此举必然会引发的羊群效应和连锁反应。在最近几年,这通常意味着在波动时期,新兴市场股票和工业周期股会被不加区分地抛售。我们认为,如果我们能够保持耐心并具备适度的勇气,这便提供了机会。我们要强调,我们不认为这会使我们的投资组合风险更高;事实上,我们认为与那些以规避波动为目的而管理的投资组合相比,它遭遇永久性资本损失的可能性更小。我们对所偏好的新兴市场和股票在未来一二十年内的经济发展信心,远高于对传统上更安全的行业和股票的信心,后者无法摆脱负债累累的英美消费者,以及发达世界大部分地区金融体系或许被夸大的盈利能力。
新兴市场投资性质的变化
过去五年里,我们一直在泛泛地谈论“新兴”市场。这个精明的营销用语已成为一个有益的简称,用来指代或许是过去两百年世界经济中最重要的变化。中国对全球制造业和商品需求日益增长的重要性、印度技术和服务业技能的挑战,以及俄罗斯和巴西的资源基础,正在改变全球增长的模式。从投资角度看,它们的重要性可能更大,因为它们是颠覆性因素,打破了众多投资者僵化的思维定式,以及许多僵化的风险模型的外推预测。这是一个千载难逢的机会。我们觉得自己有绝佳的机会来利用这些剧烈的变化,因为我们的新兴市场同事才华横溢、经验丰富,并且敢于直言不讳,危险的前设观念时常受到挑战。
越来越清楚的是,新兴市场这个标签的价值正在迅速减弱。构成这个广阔领域的各个国家、股票市场以及公司特征的具体属性、角色和局限性,随着它们力量和影响力的扩大而变得越来越关键。具有讽刺意味的是,全球化程度越高,就越需要区分不同的新兴市场。即便是投资者经常捆绑在一起的四大帝国——中国、印度、俄罗斯和巴西——也有着截然不同的优点和缺点。更关键的是,它们对全球经济发展将产生迥异的冲击。举一个相对简单的例子,未来几十年,全球许多行业的命运以及通胀压力,将由中国国内需求与俄罗斯资源供应之间的竞赛所主导。美国(和英国)的政策制定者对此平衡将几乎无能为力。
许多新兴经济体的增长前景正从依赖出口和商品优势转向国内消费者和金融部门,这进一步要求我们更具体地思考主要发展中经济体。这比我们之前的投资需要更多地对国内经济管理和前景进行分析。同时,这也要求对竞争优势进行更详细的调查,这些优势与由比较优势驱动的大宗商品公司相比,更加难以捉摸但也更为至关重要。总的来说,这正推动我们朝着比以往更广泛的新兴经济体股票和市场选择迈进。这是一种务实的方法,我们认为它应该压倒关于投资组合集中度或我们愿意支付估值的过度教条主义。
例如,我们购买了像墨西哥的 Walmex 或印度的 Infosys 这样的个股,我们认为其长期竞争优势如此显著,以至于我们不应过分关注它们当前交易中相对较高的盈利估值。我们也准备涉足那些波动可能成为常态的国家。我们认为,土耳其的 Garant 银行和南非的 Standard 银行是改善中的金融体系内运营良好的部分。我们将努力把这类国家不可避免的政治和经济情绪的波动,至少视为同样可能带来机遇的证据,而非前景永久恶化的迹象。这应是长期且真正全球化的投资组合应有的优势。
在主要发展中经济体中,我们目前对巴西的投资最多。这在一定程度上归功于其龙头企业出色的定位和业绩回报,同时也承认,稳定而负责任的经济管理正在使巴西资产异常高的风险溢价下降。去年最令人印象深刻的成就来自淡水河谷公司(CVRD),它不仅将巨额现金流重新投资于高品位、低成本铁矿石,还通过成功收购加拿大的 Inco 公司在镍市场建立了一个新的寡头垄断。我们仍然认为,这是一个远优于其他主要矿业集团所青睐的过度多元化战略的商业模式。
英国股票持仓缩减
本回顾年度的第二个主要特征是,我们大刀阔斧地削减了英国股票持仓。正如我们希望股东们已充分了解的那样,董事会和管理层担心,仍有一种挥之不去的倾向,即把英国股票视为一个独立的、且受指数影响的投资组合。因此,我们利用了英国股市普遍表现优异的一年以及英镑汇率异常强劲的机会,削减了我们的风险敞口。在过去一年中,我们实现了 2.38 亿英镑的净卖出。我们认为大部分变动已经完成,但我们也怀疑未来一年还会有进一步的卖出。这将在很大程度上取决于企业界的行动和态度。我们已减持了曾经大量持有的苏格兰皇家银行(Royal Bank of Scotland)股票,因为令人遗憾的是,我们担心目前收购荷兰银行(ABN Amro)的提议给荷银股东带来的好处,远多于给苏格兰皇家银行长期支持者带来的好处。
我们持股的技术股
去年,我们曾希望自己在科技投资中好坏参半的命运能够好转。今年我们发现情况大致相同。我们持有的几只股票在股价方面经历了艰难的一年,但在大多数情况下,我们仍然倾向于将市场的这种不看好视为增持而非卖出的机会。这项政策已经带来了一些好处,因为我们得以在现在看来是有利的价格上增持了仓位。亚马逊(Amazon)就是这项政策的一个好例子。我们也在继续增持 eBay 的股份,我们认为,一时的执行问题不必要地困扰了市场,而 eBay 品牌本身以及 PayPal 和 Skype 的力量仍在令人满意地发展。对我们来说,这些似乎是出色且可持续的经济特许权,目前被大大低估了。
在其他方面,我们感到真正失望的是,尽管全球环境活跃,SAP 的收入增长却步履蹒跚。我们对佳能(Canon)的持续进展感到满意——尽管日元大幅贬值对此有所助益。我们感到困惑的是,尽管整个东京市场疲软,我们却很难找到其他在商业吸引力或估值上能与其媲美的日本股票。
替代能源
经过长时间(可以说是过于漫长)的思考,我们买入了三只直接或间接受替代能源行业前景主导的股票。这个领域的吸引力不再仅仅取决于石油和天然气价格这一个变量,还取决于能源安全的需求以及对气候变化的担忧。这使得它们的持续发展更具可预测性,且波动更小。现在,支持来自整个政治光谱和广泛的地域,其广度是前所未有的,甚至涵盖了乔治·布什和澳大利亚。主要公用事业公司而非小众团体,现在成为了主导的客户群。
这个话题中最具挑战性的部分是评估个别公司和技术各自的竞争地位。考虑到所涉及的困难,我们认为在这个领域采取比我们通常提倡的更广泛的投资分布是更为明智的。对于太阳能尤其如此,其技术路线图和行业结构比其他细分领域更不成熟。在此我们买入了 Q Cells,它是该领域众多实力强大的德国企业之一,特别吸引我们是因为它在技术上相对中立,并拥有稳定的硅供应来源。在风能领域,已经有一个占主导地位的供应商——丹麦的维斯塔斯(Vestas),我们几乎找不到理由怀疑其持续健康发展的前景。第三只股票的受益则不那么直接,是迪尔公司(John Deere),在我们看来,随着生物燃料需求(以及农业通胀)重振长期低迷的农业需求,该公司正从半个世纪的困境中复苏。
随着时间的推移,我们希望至少能增加在这一领域的投资。在未来 12 个月内,我们希望将年底投资的 5000 万英镑翻倍。但最近的股价走势过于活跃,使我们不想立即实现这一目标。
固定收益
我们试图将用于股票投资的一贯原则应用于固定收益。我们将这些持仓视为整体投资组合的一个组成部分,而不是一个独立存在或应被单独衡量的投资组合。我们寻找的是重大的错误定价,以期为我们的股东带来长期利益。在过去一年中,有一个机会特别突出。我们开始以 90% 的实际收益率买入巴西本币通货膨胀挂钩债券。鉴于我们之前讨论过的巴西宏观经济改善,我们认为这极具吸引力。收益率现已降至 6.5%,我们认为尽管不那么非同寻常,但仍然偏高。遗憾的是,收益率的普遍压缩正使这样的机会变得越来越稀缺。
总体回顾与未来展望
过去十二个月,投资组合的活动远超我们通常乐于见到的水平(尽管 34% 的换手率按行业标准来看仍然较低)。但这次,我们认为这些变动对未来几年将大有裨益。我们相信,我们提高了所投资公司的整体素质,并且在获得更好价值的同时,更直接地接触到了世界经济令人深感兴奋的增长动力。在经历了长时间的股票市场上涨之后,我们意识到投资者可能会滋生自满情绪,并可能引发波动。如果说我们有担忧,那更集中于美国和英国金融板块过高的盈利水平,而非国际经济良好的基本健康状况。无论未来一年要面对的具体挑战是什么,我们依然对我们的投资方法充满信心,并对未来五年的前景持乐观态度。
The outcome for the year was positive with the NAV, share price and benchmark all rising 39% However, it has been a year during which months of steady equity market progress have twice been interrupted by short but violent outbreaks of turbulence In May and June of 2006 the damage took several months to repair but thus far the falls of late February and early March have proved easier to overcome Indeed from our own point of view, this most recent outbreak of volatility has been fortuitous as it enabled us to press on with the next stage of our evolution towards a truly global and index insensitive portfolio The chance to do this was accentuated by the strange way in which stock markets operate today In outbursts of turbulence the common practice amongst investment banks, hedge funds and the bulk of the investment management industry is to consult their risk models in rather the same way as many newspaper readers consult their horoscopes
- and with similar levels of success What
you should sell is determined by what has been volatile in the past even if the conditions that led to this past volatility are no longer present and despite the inevitable herding and cascading of actions that this provokes What this has tended to mean in recent years is that in periods of volatility emerging market stocks and industrial cyclicals are sold indiscriminately We think this presents opportunities if we are able to be both patient and moderately courageous We stress that we do not think that this makes our portfolio more risky, indeed we IR ANNUAL REPORT 2007 think it is less vulnerable to permanent loss of capital than those managed with avoidance of volatility in mind We have considerably more confidence in the economic development of our preferred Emerging markets and stocks over the next decade or two than we have in traditionally more secure sectors and stocks that cannot escape from the heavily indebted Anglo American consumer and the perhaps exaggerated profitability of the financial systems of much of the developed world The changing nature of Emerging market investment Over the last five years we have talked in generic terms about 'Emerging' markets This shrewd marketing phrase has become a useful shorthand for what may be the most important development in the world economy in the last two hundred years The increasing importance of China to global manufacturing and commodity demand, the challenge of Indian technology and service sector skills and the resource bases of Russia and Brazil are transforming the patterns of global growth From an investment point of view their importance may be even greater as they are disruptive factors that upset the fixed mind sets of many investors and the exirapolations of so many inflexible risk models This is an opportunity the like of which seldom occurs We feel that we have a great chance to exploit these radical changes as our Emerging market colleagues have great talent and experience and such splendidly forthright views that dangerous preconceptions are regularly challenged What is becoming clear is that the value of the Emerging markets label is fast diminishing The specific attributes, roles and limitations of the individual countries, stock markets and corporate characteristics that make up this huge field are becoming increasingly critical as their power and influence spreads Ironically the more globalisation occurs, the greater the need to differentiate between Emerging markets Even the four giant empires of China, India, Russia and Brazil that are so frequently linked by investors have profoundly different virtues and drawbacks Still more critically they will have very divergent impacts on the development of the global economy To take a comparatively simple example the fate of many industries and of inflationary pressures throughout the world will be dominaled by the race between Chinese domestic demand and Russian resource supply in the decades to come American (and British) policy makers will be virtually powerless to influence this balance The imperative to think more specifically about the major developing economies is redoubled by the shift in growth prospects away from export and commodity strength towards the domestic consumer and the financial sector in so many emerging economies This requires more analysis of domestic economic management and prospects than has been the case in our prior investments It also demands more detailed investigations of the competitive advantages that are both more nebulous and more vital than in commodity companies driven by the comparative 1 Tesco The dominant food retailer in the UK, with growing positions in non food and oversea: simplicity of resource bases and low cost production On balance this is pushing us towards a slightly broader selection of stocks and markets in the emerging economies than has been the case This is a pragmatic approach that we feel should override excessive dogmatism about the level of concentration of the portfolio or the ratings for which we are willing to pay We have, for instance, purchased individual stocks such as Walmex in Mexico or Infosys in India where we feel that the long run compettive advantages are such that we should not become too preoccupied by the comparatively high ratings of current earnings on which they trade We are also prepared to venture into countries where volatility is likely to be a constant companion We think that Garant (Turkey) and Standard Bank (South Africa) are well run parts of improving financial systems We will endeavour to view the inevitable oscillations of political and economic sentiment in such countries as at least as likely to present opportunities rather than evidence of a permanent deterioration in prospects Such ought to be the advantages of long term and genuinely global investment portfolios Amongst the major developing economies we currently have the most exposure to Brazil This is partly in tribute to the excellent positioning and returns being generated by its dominant companies and partly an acknowledgement that steady and responsible economic management is allowing the extraordinarily high risk premium on Brazilian assets to decline The most impressive achievement of last year came from CVRD which has deployed its huge cash flows both in reinvestment in high grade, low cost iron ore but has also succeeded in building a new oligopoly in the nickel market through its well executed takeover of Inco of Canada We continue to feel this is a much superior business model to the over diversified approach favoured by the other major mining groups UK reductions The second major feature of the year under review has been our vigorous pruning of UK equity holdings As we hope shareholders have become fully aware, the Board and the Managers have worried that there was still a lingering temptation to view the UK stocks as a separate portfolio and an index influenced one at that We have therefore taken the opportunity provided by a year of general out performance by British equities and of remarkable sterling strength to cut back our exposure We have made net sales of £ 238m over the course of the year We consider the bulk of our change to have been accomplished although we would also suspect that there will be further sales in the year ahead This will largely be dependant on the actions and attitudes of the corporate sector We have already reduced our once large holding in Royal Bank of Scotland as regretfully we fear that the current proposals to takeover ABN Amro offer a great deal more to shareholders of the Dutch bank than to long standing supporters of RBS itself 2 Wolseley Ferguson is the largest subsidiary of Wolseley he worlds leading distributor of heating an plumbing products Our attentions are becoming concentrated on stocks where international aspirations are high but where it is clearer to us that there is an ability to build market positions either organically or via takeovers in which scale is a more palpable benefit in driving retums Where these conditions seem to be in place we are prepared to be patient The attraction of Tesco for us lies in the gradual building of value in overseas markets and the apparent acuteness of the planned American venture in identifying an uncovered niche than in its now traditional UK dominance We have also added to our holding in Wolseley as the problems in the US housing market ought to offer more opportunities for attractive acquisitions at low prices Once again short term anxieties should be able to be turned to our advantage in an impatient world Our technology stocks Last year we were hopeful that our mixed fortunes in technology investing were set to improve We find ourselves in much the same position this year Several of our holdings have had a difficult year in stock price terms but in the majority of cases we are still minded to view this market disfavour as an opportunity to make additions rather than a prompt for sales This policy has had some benefits already as we have managed to add to holdings at prices that now appear to have been advantageous Amazon would be a good example of this policy We have also continued to add to our stake in eBay where we feel temporary execution issues have unduly bothered the SCOTTISH MORTGAGE INVESTMENT TRUST PLC DO 1 Sandvik Indian operations of Global Engineering success story Sandrik market whilst the power of not just the eBay brand itself but also of PayPal and Skype continue to develop pleasingly To us these seem to be terrific and sustainable franchises that are considerably underestimated at present Elsewhere we have been genuinely disappointed that SAP's revenue growth has faltered despite the buoyant global environment We have been pleased by the continued progress of Canon - albeit aided by the substantial fall in the yen We are puzzled that we are struggling so much to find other Japanese stocks that appear its equal in either business attraction or valuation despite the overall Tokyo market weakness Alternative energy After prolonged (arguably too prolonged) thought we have bought three stocks that are directly or indirecily dominated by prospects for the alternative energy sector The appeal of this area no longer rests on the one vanable of oil and gas pricing but on demands for energy security and concerns over climate change too This makes their continued development more predictable and less erratic Backing is now from across the political spectrum and from a wide geographical spread in a manner that was hitherto unlikely encompassing as it does George Bush and Australia Major utilities rather than esoteric communities are now the dominant customer base The most challenging part of this topic is assessing the competitive position of individual companies and technologies MANNUAL REPORT 2007 2 John Deere John Deere large frame tractors, bringing increased productivity to farmers throughout the world Given the difficulties involved we think this is an area where it is more sensible to have a broader spread of investments than we would normally propound This is particularly true of solar energy which has a still less developed technological road map and industry structure than other segments Here we have bought Q Cells which is one of many strong German enterprises in the field and which particularly appeals to us because it is both relatively technology agnostic and boasts a secure source of silicon supply In wind power there is already one dominant supplier, Vestas of Denmark, and we see little reason to be sceptical of its continued health The third stock is a less direct beneficiary, John Deere, which appears to us to be recovering from half a century of difficulties as bio-fuel requirements (and agricultural inflation) resuscitates long moribund farming demand Over the course of time we would like to see our investment in this area at least increase In the next 12 months we would like to double the £50m we had invested at the vear end Recent share price action has been too buoyant tor us to want to achieve this immediately Fixed interest We have tried to apply the same principles to fixed interest as we use in equities We rew our holdings as an integral part of he overall portfolio not as a portfolio to exist in its own right or to be measured on ts own We are looking tor major mi aluations to benefit our shareholders in the long term One opportunity has stood out for us over the last year We started buying Brazil local currency index linked bonds on a 90% real yield Given the Brazilian macroeconomic improvements that we have already discussed above we felt this to be extremely attractive Yields have now fallen to 6 5% which we consider to be still too high if less extraordinary Sadly the general compression of yields is making such opportunities increasingly scarce Overall reflections and future prospects The last twelve months has seen far more activity in the portfolio than we would normally welcome (although turnover at 34% remains low by industry standards) On this occasion we feel that the changes ought to be greatly beneficial for the years ahead We believe that we have increased the overall calibre of companies in which we invest and that we are obtaining better value whilst being more directly exposed to the deeply exciting growth dynamics of the world economy After a prolonged period of stock market gains we are aware that complacency can set in amongst investors and that volatility can ensue if we have concerns they are more focussed on the extended levels of profitability in the American and British financials sectors than on the fine fundamental health of the international economy Whatever the precise nature of challenges to be faced over the year ahead we remain confident in our investment methodology and optimistic about the prospects for the next five years