苏格兰抵押投资信托 — 经理人回顾,截至2009年3月31日年报(詹姆斯·安德森)

2009 · report · 原文约 2237 词
译文与英文原文逐段对齐可在本页展开英文,也可打开发布者原址核对上下文。
打开来源正文

过去五年里,我们有过三个战略投资观点。它们是:

• 中国的崛起(其他新兴经济体程度稍轻)将改变全球经济格局;

• 股市在过度厌恶互联网泡沫的背景下,低估了技术创新的力量;

• 西方金融体系存在危险缺陷。

我们由衷认为,这三个假设都经受住了过去 12 个月的极端考验。实际上,我们认为在这次危机期间,它们的解释力只增不减。因此,看到我们的股东在报告期内遭受如此惨重的损失,我们深感不安。不过,我们仍坚持以五年为滚动周期来评估自己,这是最低限度,因为我们深信,任何更短的周期都更可能体现运气而非能力。更危险的是,以年为单位评估往往会鼓励追逐股价的动能,而不是奖励那些利用持续机会积累逐渐增长的潜在价值的杰出公司。

We have had three strategic investment contentions over the last five years. They have been that: • the rise of China (and to a lesser extent other emerging economies! will transform the global economic scene; • stockmarkets underestimate the power of technological innovation in exaggerated revulsion to the bubble of • the Western financial systems are dangerously flawed. We sincerely believe that each of these three hypotheses have survived the extraordinary conditions of the last 12 months. Indeed we would argue that their explanatory power has only grown during this time of crisis. It has therefore thoroughly disturbed us that our shareholders have suffered so badly over the reporting period. We continue, however, to measure ourselves over rolling five year timeframes as an absolute minimum as we deeply believe that anything less is far more likely to encapsulate luck rather than skill. Even more dangerously, yearly assessment tends to endorse the pursuit of momentum in share prices rather than rewarding the gradual underlying value built by outstanding companies exploiting persistent opportunities.

因此,尽管我们对过去一年艰难困苦、损害了长期业绩记录感到抱歉,但我们只有在长期前景恶化时,才会放弃我们的主张和持有的股票,而不是因为市场悲观情绪伤害了它们的短期估值就抛售。只要重要事实没有改变,我们的投资组合也不会改变。我们的目标是做投资者,而不是投机者。

中国

十二个月前,中国正经历经济过热阶段。农业通胀、工资上涨和房地产过热都需要降温。政府政策旨在实现这一目标,并且成功了。因此,在世界金融危机爆发之前,中国正处于一个典型的、传统的自身经济周期中。可以说,我们应该更早关注中国国内的发展态势,因为中国股市——尽管存在种种缺陷——已经表明,先是通胀,然后是工业和房地产放缓,都是严重的问题。

Therefore whilst we are sorry that the last year has been so tough land damaging to our longer term record! we will only abandon our contentions and our stocks when their long-un prospects have deteriorated rather than when the dreadful mood of the market has hurt their immediate valuation. Unless the important facts change nor will our portfolio. We aim to be investors not speculators. China Twelve months ago China was suffering from a phase of economic overheating. Agricultural inflation, wage increases and property exuberance all needed to be dampened down. Government policy was aimed at accomplishing this. It succeeded. China was therefore enjoying a classic, traditional economic cycle of its own before the onset of the world financial crisis. Arguably we should have been paying even more attention to developments in China as the domestic stockmarket, for all its faults, indicated that first inflation and then the industrial and real estate slowdown were serious issues.

OH 年报 2009

自去年秋天全球金融危机以来,中国的结构性优势却已充分显现。与西方困境以及处境不佳的发展中国家形成鲜明对比,令人惊叹。中国大规模货币刺激已传导至银行信贷复苏,而财政扩张空间虽被利用但远未耗尽。这似乎正转化为经济早且迅猛的复苏,尽管出口下滑令人担忧。目前我们预计,2009 年中国将占全球增长总量的 150%。尽管这一应对措施在规模和表面成功上都令人印象深刻,但同样至关重要的是,我们要思考中国演变的长期影响。我们既不希望暗示不存在严峻挑战,也不希望暗示中国共产党已发现经济管理的永恒秘诀。

OH ANNUAL REPORT 2009 Since the global financial crisis of last autumn China's structural strengths have, however, been seen in full relief. The contrast with the travails of the West as well as with less well-positioned developing nations is startling. China's dramatic monetary stimulus is already feeding through to renewed bank lending whilst the room for fiscal expansion has been exploited but far from exhausted. This appears to be translating into an early and dramatic recovery of the economy despite the much feared export decline. At present we would expect China to account for up to 150% of total world growth in 2009. Whilst this response has been formidable both in scale and apparent success it is every bit as important for us to contemplate the long term implications of China's evolution. We do not wish to imply either that there are not severe challenges or that the Chinese Communist Party has discovered the eternal secrets of economic management.

未来一年,银行业需要确保货币刺激措施流向生产性投资而非投机。超越这一时限,调整经济结构——从出口转向内需市场、从东部转向西部、从沿海城市转向内陆乡村——是重大挑战。我们并非对此束手无策。中国在过去 20 年的发展中已建成全球最大的汽车市场,并在过去十年间拥有全球最多的互联网用户。医疗领域的合理改革似乎也指日可待。我们面临的挑战在于,如何在投资组合中反映中国经济结构的变迁。从出口向内需消费的转型,乃至大宗商品使用增速的放缓,都意味着我们需要更多地在大中华区的本土企业中寻找投资机会,这已超出我们以往策略的范畴。

In the next year the banking system needs to ensure that the monetary stimulus is channelled into productive investment rather than speculation. Beyond this timeframe the need to shift the balance of the economy from exports to the internal market, from East to West, from the cities of the coast to the rural interior are major challenges. We would not despair that they can be accomplished. China has already delivered the world's largest car market over 20 years of progress and the world's largest internet user base over a decade. Sensible reforms to healthcare too seem The challenge for us is to reflect the changing nature of the Chinese economy in our portfolio. The shift towards domestic consumption and away from exports and even a moderation in the use of commodities mean that exposure more often needs to be sought in Greater China's own companies rather more than has been our historic policy.

在中国同事姚万义的大力协助下,我们正逐步抓住机会推进这一进化。我们对腾讯、招商银行、百度以及中国移动的持股,都应从这个角度来理解。随着中国与台湾地区关系的日益缓和,台积电或许也应被列入这份名单。

巴西国家石油公司拥有巨大的未开发石油储量。

俄罗斯、巴西和印度

在世界经济增长的其他关键新兴市场,应对危机的成效不那么显著。最明显的受挫者是俄罗斯。这损害了我们的投资组合。许多寡头对债务融资的过度渴求,以及资源行业庞大的资本需求已经暴露无遗。我们认为这些困难并非无法克服,但它们确实降低了我们此前的热情。我们卖掉了诺里尔斯克镍业——寡头债务为政府加大干预打开了大门——并减持了俄罗斯天然气工业股份公司的仓位,因为当前能源价格使其庞大的投资计划面临问题。

With the considerable assistance of my Chinese colleague Wanyi Yao we are gradually embarking on this evolution as opportunities permit. Our holdings in Tencent, China Merchants Bank, and Baidu.com as well as in China Mobile should be seen in this light. With the burgeoning rapprochement between China and Taiwan, TSMC might appropriately be included in this list. 1 Petrobras Petrobras, huge unexploited oil reserves. Russia, Brazil and India In the other key emerging markets for world growth the response to crisis has been less overwhelmingly successful. The most obvious casualty has been Russia. This has hurt our portfolio. The exaggerated appetite for debt finance displayed by many oligarchs and the large capital needs of the resource industry have been shown up. We do not think that these developments are insurmountable but they do moderate our prior enthusiasm. We have sold Norilsk Nickel where oligarch debt has opened the door to increased state machinations and cut back our position in Gazprom as current energy prices make the enormous investment programme problematic.

我们没有进一步减持的计划。

在我们持有的巴西资产上,我们丝毫不觉得有必要道歉。巴西经济当前确实有些疲软,但没有任何迹象显示它会失去基本面的平衡。我们既乐于借钱给巴西政府(通过持有其长期通胀保值债券),也愿意为巴西国家石油公司(Petrobras)的投资需求提供支持。在我们看来,该公司在巴西近海惊人的石油发现,远比现货油价的大幅波动重要得多。这些项目的回报要在多年后才能兑现,而成本状况正在改善——因为除了巴西国家石油公司,几乎没几家公司有能力投资这类资产。换句话说,我们对巴西国家石油公司的热情,是基于它自身的长期前景,而不是对月度油价走势的投机。

We have no plans to make any further reductions. We feel no such need for apology in the case of our substantial Brazilian holdings. The economy is enduring some current weakness but shows no signs of losing its fundamental balance. We are happy both to loan money to the Brazilian government (via our long term inflation protected bond holding) and to back the investment needs of Petrobras. Their remarkable oil discoveries in offshore Brazil seem to us to be much more significant than the wild oscillations of the spot oil price. The rewards for these projects are years ahead whilst the cost equation is improving as few apart from Petrobras are in a position to invest in such assets. To put it another way our enthusiasm for Petrobras is based on its own long term prospects not on a speculation about the course of monthly oil prices.

印度呈现出令人鼓舞的迹象,它受金融危机的冲击程度,似乎小于去年初通胀压力和过热带来的影响。我们的问题仍然是:如何以合理价格找到有吸引力的公司。我们赞赏 Hero Honda(摩托车)和 HDFC(住房抵押贷款)这两家公司应对行业挑战的方式。

2 Google

Google,高度创新的搜索引擎,持续开发新的用途。

科技

去年最令人费解的体验之一,莫过于秋季我们持有的科技股股价表现惨淡。这让我们困惑,因为我们想不出还有哪些公司比它们更有能力安然度过这场危机。整个行业,尤其是我们持有的那些公司,普遍拥有极其强劲的现金头寸,并且非常适应通缩型交易环境。正如我们对其股价急剧下跌感到不安一样,现在我们也很高兴看到种种迹象表明,这些业务的优势正得到认可。

India shows encouraging signs of suffering less from the financial crisis than it did from the inflationary pressures and overheating of early last year. Our problem remains identifying attractive companies at reasonable prices. We admire the manner in which both Hero Honda (motorbikes) and HDFC (mortgage finance) are navigating their sectoral challenges. 2 Google Google, highly innovative search engine continually developing new uses. Technology Possibly the most puzzling experience of last year was the abject share price performance of our technology stocks in the autumn. This puzzles us because we can think of few companies that are in a better position to ride out the crisis. The industry in general, and the companies that we own in particular, tend to have extremely strong cash positions and are well used to deflationary trading conditions. Just as we were disturbed by their sharp declines so we are now pleased that there is every indication that the strengths of these businesses are being acknowledged.

事实上,从亚马逊到谷歌,再到苹果,都有明显迹象表明,创新和结构性变革在艰难时期往往会被放大,而这些公司不仅是在生存,更是在蓬勃发展。尽管这三家公司的优点正逐渐以不同方式被市场认可,但在相关领域,仍有其他股票由于尚未获得投资青睐而让我们愈发感到兴奋。最典型的一个例子是任天堂:这家公司通过对游戏行业的差异化思考持续创造高回报和强劲现金流。当市场为汇率和月度销售数据担忧时,我们乐于继续增持其股份。遗憾的是,在日本企业界的荒原上,我们找不到其他类似吸引力的选择。我们依然坚持投资领先的替代能源企业。

Indeed from Amazon to Google to Apple there are clear indications that both innovation and structural changes tend lo be magnified in tough times and that these companies are actually thriving rather than merely surviving. Whilst the virtues of these three companies are gradually and variably being recognised by the markets there are still other stocks in related areas that we are increasingly enthused by as they remain out of investment favour. The principal example of this is Nintendo, which continues to churn out high returns and generate impressive cash flow by thinking differently about the gaming industry. We are delighted to continue to add to our holding as the market worries about exchange rates and monthly sales figures. Sadly we can find nothing else of similar attractions in the wastelands of the Japanese corporate sector. We maintain our belief in investing in leading alternative energy businesses.

我们可以理解它们过去一年表现疲弱的原因 ——(与上述公司不同)它们的业务确实需要银行和项目融资渠道。但我们不认为,在充满挑战但暂时性的环境下,它们的前景和价值已被摧毁。事实上,那些财务实力相对雄厚、竞争优势突出的企业,很可能在走出这轮低迷后,其地位比我们原先估计的还要稳固。我们确信维斯塔斯(风电)和第一太阳能(薄膜太阳能)就是这种情况;同时我们也希望(虽然信心稍弱),另一家太阳能公司 Q-Cells 依然能保持这种态势。在我们看来,全球最重要的两个政府正越来越坚定地投入替代能源发展。这一点在美国和中国都显得迫在眉睫,不过我们需要非常审慎地观察中国在该领域投资所带来的竞争影响。

We can understand their weak showings over the last year as (unlike the companies above) they do need access to bank and project finance. Yet we do not think that their prospects and value has been destroyed by challenging but temporary circumstances. Indeed those with relatively strong financial and competitive advantages may well emerge from this downturn in even stronger positions than we had estimated. We certainly judge that this is the case for Vestas (wind] and First Solar (thin film) whilst we hope, with less confidence, that this remains so for its fellow solar company Q-Cells. It seems to us that the two most important governments in the world are increasingly committed to alternative energy development. This is imminently important in both America and China although we will need to observe the competitive implications of Chinese investment in this area very carefully.

西方金融崩盘后的余波

长期以来,我们一直对西方金融业过度灌输的复杂性、杠杆化和贪婪深感忧虑。我们的直接敞口很低。如果完全没有敞口会更好。然而,相比我们的命运,更关键的是雷曼兄弟倒闭后金融体系的完全冻结。我们坦承感到惊讶:银行业令人不齿的行为,竟导致其无法向实体经济提供甚至最基本的金融服务——这种情况至少自 1930 年代以来从未出现过,甚至可以说几个世纪以来都未曾有。这种局面无法长期持续,正在逐步得到纠正,但即使是信贷的暂时停摆,也已严重损害了全球经济。

这一连串令人痛心的事件,会如何影响我们对金融业的态度?

The Aftermath of the Western Financial Debacle We had long been concerned by the complexities, gearing and greed inculcated by far too much of the Western financial sector. Our direct exposure has been low. It would have been better if it had been non existent. This, however, was less critical to our fortunes than the complete freezing of the financial system after the lehman collapse. We confess to surprise that the deplorable conduct of the banking industry translated into an inability to provide even the most basic financial services to the real economy in a manner not seen at least since the 1930's and arguably not for several centuries. This situation was untenable for long and is being gradually corrected but even the temporary stoppage of credit has severely damaged the global economy. Where does this sad series of events leave our attitude to the financial sector?

我们想说,银行业管理层正在回归他们过去那种沉闷的声誉和更朴素的薪酬结构,但我们几乎看不到证据表明这是真的。从巴克莱到高盛,没有任何迹象表明复杂度降低或贪婪减少。与此同时,国家通过注资来重组银行体系的做法,在我们看来并不令人满意。像花旗这样老朽的组织正在苟延残喘,让人联想起日本的“僵尸银行”,而英国或美国的政治环境则阻止了像瑞典在银行业危机后那样有效的全面国有化。这些弊端似乎会削弱那些经营更为稳健、以股东而非内部人利益为中心的金融机构所能获得的利益。不过,一些好处仍将存在,形式是新业务的利差扩大,以及通过有机增长和收购扩张的资产负债表实力。

We would like to say that bank managements are demonstrating a return to their dull reputations of yore and to less exotic reward structures but we see little evidence that this is true. From Barclays to Goldman Sachs there is no evidence of less complexity or reduced avarice. At the same time the refinancing of banking systems by state injection appears to us to be less than satisfactory. Creaking organisations such as Citi are being kept alive in an echo of Japanese 'zombie' banks whilst politics in Britain or America prevents full state control in the manner that served Sweden so well after its banking crisis. These drawbacks seem likely to lessen the available benefits for those financial institutions that have been both more prudently run and that have the interests of shareholders rather than insiders at their heart. Some benefits will, however, remain in the shape of higher spreads on new business and the balance sheet strength to expand organically and by acquisition.

正是在这种精神下,我们持有伯克希尔·哈撒韦(巴菲特先生可以借此利用保险承保容量收缩的机会),以及桑坦德银行(博廷先生能够收获他此前审慎经营的成果,这在他参与那笔命运攸关的荷兰银行交易中已得到体现)。

汉年度报告 2009

2 桑坦德银行

桑坦德银行,增长战略与更审慎放贷的结合。

结论与展望

随着时间的推移,我们认为 2008-09 年的危机将被视为西方衰落和中国崛起的标志性事件。这一结果究竟是西方的绝对衰落还是相对衰落,在很大程度上取决于,在金融和人口挑战加剧之际,政治领袖是否具备远见卓识。在这方面,我们对美国的进展比英国更感鼓舞。中国的崛起过程不太可能一帆风顺,但也很可能涵盖从国防关系到全球货币体系等迄今变化甚微的领域。

It is in this spirit that we own Berkshire Hathaway where the shrinking of insurance capacity can be exploited by Mr Buffett and Banco Santander where Snr. Botin can reap the advantages of his prior prudence as demonstrated in his part of the fateful ABN Amro deal. HANNUAL REPORT 2009 2 Banco Santander Banco Santander a combination of growth strategy coupled with more prudent lending. Conclusion and Outlook Over time we think that the crisis of 2008-9 will come to be seen as a defining event in the decline of the West and the rise of China. Whether this proves an absolute decline of the West or merely a relative one depends heavily on far-sighted political leadership as the financial and demographic challenges rise. We are more encouraged by progress in America than Britain on this score. The rise of China is unlikely to be smooth but it is also likely to encompass areas as yet little changed from defence relations to the global monetary system.

我们也怀疑,即便是最执迷于数学的风险建模者,最终也会看清一个事实:风险更多出在西方,而非那些新兴大国。未来一年,恐怕会有不少意外发生。尽管过去一年经历了许多波折,但这些意外既可能是正面,也可能是负面的。在我们看来,全球范围内货币与财政宽松的规模之大,加上信贷紧缩的缓解、一轮恶性库存周期的结束,以及大宗商品繁荣的骤然崩溃,正在对全球经济施加极为强劲的扩张力量。不排除动物精神重新焕发生机的可能。未来的前景中,通胀而非通缩,也是完全可能出现的。我们将努力在这重重挑战中摸索前行,同时铭记市场在短期内的不可预测性。

We suspect too that it will become evident even to the most determined mathematical risk modellers that danger lies more in the West than in the emerging giants. In the coming year we suspect that there will be many surprises. These are just as likely to be positive as negative despite the experiences of the last year. It appears to us that the scale of monetary and fiscal easing globally combined with the easing of the credit squeeze, a vicious inventory cycle and the sharp collapse of a commodily boom are now exerting very expansionary forces on the global economy. It is not inconceivable that animal spirits revive. It is conceivable that inflation rather than deflation is in eventual prospect. We will endeavour to plot our way around these challenges whilst remembering just how unpredictable markets can be in the shortrun.

去年经历了历史性的暴跌,将长达十年的股市回报率拉入负值区间。这种状况非同寻常,表明市场已经消化了长期深度衰退和企业盈利大幅下降的预期。这样的氛围很容易成为投资的绝佳时机,而悲观则显得值得怀疑。

我们依然坚信过去五年指引我们的投资流程和经济观点。我们旗下公司的价值不在于下一个季度或下一年的盈利,而在于它们数十年间为股东创造现金流的能力。我们总会犯错,但我们确实相信,与一年前相比,我们旗下多数公司的处境更强而非更弱。大多数情况下,这是因为它们能够参与新兴经济体的财富增长,它们的竞争地位因有缺陷的金融模式崩溃而得到加强,或者它们的前景建立在非凡的创新之上。

Last year saw falls of historic proportions bringing decade long capital returns on equities into negative territory. This is unusual and suggests that a prolonged deep recession and savage corporate earnings falls are already discounted by markets. Such an atmosphere could easily prove a splendid time to invest and a questionable one at which to become pessimistic. We maintain our belief in both our investment process and the economic viewpoints that have guided us over the last five years. The value of our companies lies not in the earnings of the next quarter or year but in their ability to deliver cash flows for their shareholders over decades. We will always make mistakes but we genuinely believe that more of our companies are in a stronger rather than a weaker position than a year ago. In the bulk of these cases it is because they can participate in the rising wealth of the emerging economies, that their competitive positions have been strengthened by the collapse of flawed financial models, or that their prospects are built on exceptional innovation.

尽管过去一年困难重重,我们并不认为,现在或将来,这个全球投资组合的框架有什么可让我们感到羞愧的。

For all the difficulties of the last year we do not think that this is a framework for a global portfolio which we should be at all ashamed of now or in the future.